Costco and Sam's Club Membership Shakeup: A Comparative Analysis
Costco announces exclusive benefit for premium members: Additional rewards program enhancement.
In the competitive world of wholesale retailers, Costco and Sam's Club continue to duke it out for customers' wallets and time. Let's explore the current membership perks, recent changes, and the notorious price tag for both giants.
Costco Executive Membership: The High-Roller Tier
Core Perks:- 2% Annual Reward: Executive members reap a 2% rebate on most purchases, up to $1,250 annually.- Early Shopping Access: Commencing June 30, 2025, Executive members can revel in an hour of premium shopping before the rest of the pack.- Service Discounts: Executive members indulge in discounted travel, auto buying, and various other services.- Additional Perks: A treasure trove of benefits awaits, including a $150 worth of services savings and a $10 monthly Instacart credit.- All Gold Star Benefits: Access to Costco's warehouse deals, online shopping, and flexible return policies.
Recent Changes and Cost:- Early Shopping: Though absent for a spell, Costco's Early Shopping privileges have been brought back to life for Executive members.- Price Increase: The Executive Membershipnow sets you back $130 per year (previously less).- Membership Demographics: Executive members make up 45-50% of Costco's membership base but account for a whopping 73% of total sales.
Sam's Club Membership: Let's Compare
COST
Core Perks:- Club and Plus Tiers: Sam's Club sports a dual-tier system similar to Costco.- Cash Rewards: Plus members (the higher tier) pocket a 2% rebate on qualifying purchases up to $500 annually.- Early Shopping: Plus members snag early shopping hours on select weekends and holidays.- Free Shipping: Plus members enjoy complimentary shipping on most online orders (with minimum requirements).- Instant Savings: Access to special, members-only discounts.- Pharmacy and Optical Discounts: All members pocket savings on pharmacy and optical products.- Sam’s Club Mastercard: Extra cash rewards on fuel, dining, and travel.- Low-Price Guarantee: Competitive pricing and customer satisfaction guarantee.
COSTCO WHOLESALE CORP.
Price Comparison:- Club Membership: $50 annually (basic).- Plus Membership: $110 annually (premium).- Sam’s Club’s membership costs significantly less than Costco’s Executive tier, especially following Costco's recent price hike.[5]
990.21
Head-to-Head: Costco Executive vs. Sam’s Club Plus
-12.50
| Feature | Costco Executive | Sam’s Club Plus ||-----------------------|---------------------|------------------------|| Annual Fee | $130 | ~$110 || Cashback/Reward | 2% up to $1,250/year| 2% up to $500/year || Early Shopping | Yes (1 hour daily) | Yes (select times) || Free Shipping | No | Yes (Plus, min. spend) || Service Discounts | Yes | Yes (pharmacy, optical)|| Instacart Credit | $10/month | No || Additional Perks | $150/year in services | Instant savings, Mastercard rewards|| Membership Base | ~45-50% of members | Not specified || Share of Sales | 73% | Not specified |
-1.25%
Evolution Over Time
- Costco: In recent days, Costco brought back Early Shopping hours for Executive members, hiked membership fees, and introduced new perks like Instacart credits and service discounts.
- Sam’s Club: Though offering affordable pricing and free shipping for Plus members, Sam's Club provides fewer service-related discounts (like travel or auto program savings) compared to Costco.
Powered By
In A Nutshell
Costco's Executive Membership shines with recent perks reinstated, new benefits added, and a higher price point (than Sam’s Club Plus Membership). Sam's Club offers a less expensive premium membership with a sharp focus on online shopping and instant savings, but with fewer service-related perks compared to Costco now. Both provide early shopping access for their top-tier members, but Costco's recent changes have significantly augmented the value proposition for its Executive members.
In the comparison between Costco's Executive Membership and Sam's Club's Plus Membership, Costco's Executive tier, now priced at $130 annually, offers a 2% annual reward and includes early shopping access, service discounts, additional perks, and Instacart credit. On the other hand, Sam's Club Plus Membership, approximately costing $110 annually, provides a 2% reward, early shopping hours on select weekends, free shipping (with minimum requirements), instant savings, and pharmacy and optical discounts. While both memberships offer early shopping access, Costco has recently introduced new perks like Instacart credits and service discounts, significantly enhancing its value proposition for Executive members. The finance industry underscores that Sam's Club's membership costs significantly less than Costco's Executive tier, especially following Costco's recent price hike.
