Skip to content

Trump's economy veered away from traditional Republican economic doctrines

President's Strategy for Second Term Embraces Spontaneous Government-run Capitalism in America

Trump's economy departs from traditional Republican economic strategy
Trump's economy departs from traditional Republican economic strategy

Trump's economy veered away from traditional Republican economic doctrines

In the final years of the Trump administration, a notable shift in economic policies has been observed. Companies under his leadership have increasingly prioritized political favor over innovation and competition.

This change has been criticized by economists such as Veronique de Rugy, a senior research fellow at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University. De Rugy argues that Trump acts like a state capitalist but is more accurately described as a "daddy capitalist."

Trump's industrial policy encourages "hyper-activist corporate lobbying," with large and well-connected enterprises getting the best 'deals'. This shift in resources from productive activity to lobbying occurs due to Trump's policies, undermining fairness and growth.

The government's acquisition of a 10% stake in Intel by the Trump administration, for instance, would be labeled as socialism if proposed by anyone other than President Trump.

Trump's erratic improvisation in governance erodes institutional safeguards and trust in markets without delivering durable alternatives. His economic policies are characterized as erratic, transactional, and short-sighted, and a rejection of the "quietly overbearing 'Nanny State'."

The Trump administration's protectionism and tariffs would have been inconceivable a decade ago. These policies, along with his approach to the economy, differ from past Republican playbooks, as he treats the market as a stage for negotiation to reorganize the world's economies.

Mariana Mazzucato, author of "The Entrepreneurial State," sees Trump's approach to industrial policy as "gestures without purpose, interventions without coordination and spending without strategy."

Despite these state capitalism exercises, the classical liberal consensus is expected to endure due to its past success. Trump's behavior creates profound uncertainty in the market, as investment and risk-taking give way to hesitation due to unpredictable rules.

Michael Strain of the American Enterprise Institute suggests that Trump's most enduring legislative achievement, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, moves the tax code in a more pro-market direction. However, Trump's actions are not building a sustainable model of state capitalism, but are eroding trust in markets and institutions.

This shift towards "daddy capitalism" has sparked controversy, with groups promoting the new form of state capitalism in the USA under President Trump including Trump himself, who seeks to align large American corporations with his political power, and loyalists placed in key institutions like the Federal Reserve.

On the other hand, those rejecting this shift include independent institutions such as the judiciary and the Federal Reserve officials not aligned with Trump, critics who see this as a corruption of democratic and free-market principles, and broader opposition figures concerned about authoritarian tendencies and threats to market freedoms.

Articles such as Hiltzik's discussion of rebuilding what Trump is tearing down, while another suggests potential trouble ahead in Trump's economic promises, reflect the ongoing debate about the long-term implications of Trump's economic policies.

Read also:

Latest