Unseen Objects Soaring High Above Us, Yet Danger Remains Undervalued
In the bustling world of stock market newcomers, Circle has been making waves since its debut on the New York Stock Exchange on June 5. The company's stock price has soared by over 800 percent, currently being celebrated by investors. However, beneath this positive surface lies a potential vulnerability in Circle's business model.
The subscriber-based news service, DER AKTIONÄR, offers exclusive insights into this matter, but access to the full article requires a subscription fee of 9.95 € for one month.
Despite the significant growth in Circle's stock price, the company's business model has a major vulnerability: its heavy reliance on interest income generated from USDC reserves. This dependency makes Circle highly sensitive to macroeconomic factors, particularly U.S. interest rate changes. In 2024, 99.1% of Circle’s $1.676 billion revenue came from interest on reserves, primarily invested in U.S. Treasury bills. If the Federal Reserve were to cut interest rates, Circle’s earnings could be severely impacted, as lower rates would reduce the interest income that underpins the bulk of its revenue.
Additional vulnerabilities facing Circle include high distribution costs, rising competition, and valuation concerns. Although minting USDC stablecoins is nearly costless, Circle pays substantial fees to exchanges like Coinbase (which took $900 million or 54% of Circle’s revenue) and Binance, eroding Circle’s pricing power and margins.
As stablecoin regulations advance, more competitors—especially regulated stablecoin issuers—are expected to enter the market, threatening Circle’s dominant USDC market share and exerting downward pressure on its stock. Analysts warn that Circle’s valuation is stretched, trading at much higher multiples compared to diversified fintechs like Coinbase or Robinhood. Circle’s concentrated revenue stream contrasts with Coinbase’s broader financial service lines, raising concerns about scalability and risk exposure.
In summary, Circle's core vulnerability lies in its business model’s dependence on high interest rates for income and the risk of increased competition limiting its growth and profitability, despite strong stock momentum post-IPO. As investors continue to show positive response towards Circle, it is crucial to consider these potential risks to make informed decisions.
Investors considering Circle as an investment opportunity should be aware that, despite its impressive stock performance, the company's business model is heavily dependent on interest income from USDC reserves, making it sensitive to changes in U.S. interest rates. Furthermore, the company faces additional threats such as high distribution costs, rising competition, and concerns about its valuation compared to other fintech companies.
